.357 SIG Defensive Ammo: Effective and Underrated

The .357 Sig (or 9x22mm) may not have set the handgun world on fire quite the way Federal and SIG Sauer had hoped it would, but that isn't necessarily the round’s fault. Since its introduction in 1994, it has gained a niche yet loyal following and proven itself a worthy defensive cartridge.
But not all .357 Sig is created equal. Is is always the case, some rounds are better fired at the range than in self-defense. Many others don't belong in your pistol to begin with.
Let's cut straight to the picnic. The best .357 Sig defense ammo is Speer Gold Dot 125 grain JHP (aka GDHP).
Other options are well worth considering, however – especially if you like to experiment with your carry ammo whilst finding the best possible fit for you and your gun.
Enough yammering. Dig my picks.
Best .357 Sig Ammo for Self Defense
- Speer Gold Dot 125 Grain JHP - Best Overall
- Federal Personal Defense HST 125 Grain JHP - Law Enforcement Favorite
- Federal Premium 125 Grain JHP - Best Value
Speer Gold Dot 125 Grain JHP- Best Overall
Specs
- Bullet Type: Gold Dot Jacketed Hollow Point (JHP)
- Bullet Weight: 125 Grains
- Muzzle Velocity: 1375 fps
- Muzzle Energy: 525 ft-lbs
- Casing Type: Nickel-Plated Brass
Pros
- Proven track record in law enforcement use
- Nickel-plated case promotes reliable functionality
- Outstandingly reliable terminal ballistics
- Meets or exceeds FBI penetration standards
Cons
- Costlier than several serviceable alternatives
- Poor availability at times
Why I Chose It
Speer Gold Dot is the premier choice of hollow point ammo, and has proven itself in the hands of local and federal law enforcement officers for many moons now.
This .357 Sig ammo functioned reliably in every semi-automatic handgun we tested, including my own Glock 32 concealed carry and some other dude's SIG P229 Nitron.
These 125 grain JHP loadss pass the FBI's own test protocol – a testament to the Gold Dot JHP's consistently effective penetration depth and terminal expansion. It owes these feats to its bonded copper jacket, as well as its precision-formed hollow point nose cavity. And at 525 ft-lbs, this round's muzzle energy leaves nothing to be desired.
Other .357 SIG Ammunition Recommendations for Defense
Federal Personal Defense HST 125 Grain JHP
Specs
- Bullet Type: HST Jacketed Hollow Point (JHP)
- Bullet Weight: 125 Grains
- Muzzle Velocity: 1360 fps
- Muzzle Energy: 513 ft-lbs
- Case: Nickel-Plated Brass
Pros
- Ideal terminal performance in ballistics testing
- Proven HST bullet design
- Successfully implemented by countless law enforcement officers
- Light recoil
Cons
- Expensive
Why We Chose It
Federal Personal Defense HST is another legitimate contender in the world of defensive ammunition. Like Speer Gold Dot, this high-quality ammo is loaded with nickel-plated brass cases that promote more reliable feeding. It also features sealed primers that can spell the difference between a bang and a click when you need a bang most.
The HST bullet is designed to conserve mass as it travels through soft tissue while simultaneously undergoing broad expansion, thereby achieving ideal wound column depth and width. A potent one-two combo. Like our top pick, this round meets FBI test protocol standards and is implemented by numerous law enforcement agencies across the land.
Federal Tactical HST 125 Grain JHP
Specs
- Bullet Type: HST Jacketed Hollow Point (JHP)
- Bullet Weight: 125 Grains
- Muzzle Velocity: 1360 fps
- Muzzle Energy: 513 ft-lbs
- Case: Nickel-Plated Brass
Pros
- Ideal terminal performance in ballistics testing
- Proven HST bullet design
- Successfully implemented by countless law enforcement officers
- Light recoil
Cons
- Expensive
Why We Chose It
We can't say anything about Federal's .357 SIG Tactical HST 125 grain JHP that we haven't already said about their Personal Defense HST variant. That's because Tactical HST is identical save for one difference: it is packaged in 50-round boxes instead of 20.
The downside? You're obligated to buy at least two-and-a-half times more ammo. The upside? You'll pay less per round when you buy the larger box. In my book, cheaper ammo is worth any price.
Honorable Mentions
There are a few other options that we either haven’t tested in a wide enough variety of guns (yet) or that we’re waiting on manufacturers to restock. These are rounds that I personally trust, made by manufacturers with reputations for quality.
Hornady Critical Duty .357 SIG 135 Grain FlexLock: A solid performer that features Hornady’s no-clog Flex-Tip projectile, which has an InterLock band that helps it remain more intact and penetrate deeper. This round also passes the FBI test protocl, and features specially formulated low-flash propellant that preserves the shooter's vision in dark environments.
Underwood .357 SIG 147 Grain JHP: Another great option featuring Hornady’s field-proven XTP hollow point bullets, nickel-plated cases, and low-flash powder.
Winchester Defender 125 Grain Bonded JHP: Winchester’s bonded jacketed hollow point fully satisfies FBI test protocol. The resilient projectile excels at passing through barriers without shedding a significant amount of its weight.
Remington Golden Saber 125 Grain JHP: Another law enforcement favorite, Remington’s Golden Saber line is a great option that functions well, dand doesn't break the bank.
Fiocchi 124 Grain FMJTC: This one is designed for target shooting – not personal defense. Its angular bullet would punch a pretty harmful wound into soft tissue all the same, however, making it an suitable backup for when you've run out of premium JHP loads.
If you’re looking to shoot an IDPA or USPSA match, pick up some of this stuff instead of firing your top-shelf carry loads.
Buyer’s Guide: The Importance of Selecting the Right Defensive Ammo (.357 SIG or Otherwise)
Are you choosing ammo that you would rely on while defending your life? Then there are a few important factors to consdier: reliability, penetration, and terminal expansion.
You need ammo that is going to function reliably in your gun. You need bullets that are going to penetrate deeply enough to do the job. Expanding bullets are also a must, as they (A) maximize trauma to the threat, and (B) reduce the risk of over-penetration that could harm innocent bystanders.
The .357 SIG may have been designed to mimic the .357 Magnum when fired from a semi-auto handgun, but that doesn’t mean you can skimp and shoot a typical target FMJ instead of a purpose-built JHP and expect to stop a threat as effectively.
Factors to Consider when Selecting .357 Sig Self-Defense Ammo
Choosing a .357 SIG round for everyday carry means picking something that is going to expand consistently, defeat barriers like thick clothing, plywood or drywall, and still penetrate deeply enough to cause significant trauma to a vital organ.
That means the ammunition you choose needs to be loaded with high-quality controlled-expansion hollow points that penetrate 12”-16” in ballistic gelatin.
Why that range? Because it is indicitave of a projectile that can penetrate deeply enough to access a threat's vital organ (even if said threat is shielded by a common urban barrier), but which will also not pass clean through the threat and potentially injure a bystander. We want a bullet that expends all of its energy on the assailant – not whatever lies beyond the them.
Let’s take a look at the types of bullets that can provide this type of performance.
Types of .357 Sig Defense Ammunition: Bullet Types Explained
Full Metal Jacket (FMJ): An FMJ consists of a lead core with a (usually) copper shell (which leaves the core exposed at the base). Economical and ideal for target shooting; non-expanding, and less than ideal for personal protection.
Total Metal Jacket (TMJ): A TMJ is identical to an FMJ in form and function save for one difference: its lead core is not exposed at the base. It therefore fails to produce lead gas on ignition, which promotes a cleaner firearm and a healthier training environment.
Jacketed Hollow Point (JHP): A JHP is the most widely preferred bullet for defense. Its hollow point nose cavity causes the bullet to mushroom to almost twice its initial diameter while penetrating soft tissue. This effectively turns a .357 caliber projectile into a .70+ caliber projectile after striking an assailant.
It's terminal performance makes the JHP more effective at stopping a threat, as well as less likely to injure an innocent bystander positioned just behind said threat.
Solid Copper Hollow Point (SCHP): An SCHP is monolithic: 100% copper, without a lead core. This clean-shooting projectile exhibits stellar weight retention and expansion characteristics, making it a highly effective solution for defense.
How to Test 357 Sig Defense Ammo
So long as you’re going with an expanding projectile by a reputable name in the industry, you don’t really need to break out the ballistics gel while testing your defensive ammo. Odds are that somebody online has already done that for you.
What neither I nor anyone else on the internet can do for you is test your chosen defensive ammo in your gun.
Defensive firearms have gotten a lot less picky about bullet weights and projectile profiles over the years, but it's still important that you take your ammo to the range and test it extensively. I personally go through about three or four boxes or so of my chosen ammo each time to make sure it functions reliably in a new gun.
I know that’s expensive, but I’d rather know my ammo works. At the bare minimum, fire a couple of full mags at real-world distances. Pick a handgun self-defense drill and run through it a few times to make sure your gun will cycle your chosen ammo well.
Real-World Effectiveness of .357 SIG Defense Ammo
Despite its relative unpopularity, the .357 SIG has repeatedly proven its efficacy in real-world defensive scenarios. The Texas Highway Patrol and the state police forces of Delaware, Mississippi, Montana, New Mexico, North Carolina, Oklahoma, Rhode Island, Tennessee, and Virginia have all used .357 SIG duty weapons. So too have the Secret Service, Bureau of Industry and Security, Air Marshals, Customs and Border Patrol.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the difference between 9x22mm ammo and .357 sig ammo?
There is no difference between 9x22mm ammo and .357 Sig ammo. They are the same rounds.
Is the .357 Sig too much for self-defense?
No, the .357 Sig is not too much for self-defense. It's designed for that very application.
Can you use the .357 Sig for home defense?
Yes, you can use the .357 Sig for home defense.
Is .357 Sig a good defensive round?
Yes, the .357 Sig is a good defensive round. Even though it's not the most popular cartridge, it's more than capable of stopping a threat.
Parting Shots
The .357 Sig is a great option for self-defense, with a lot of great factory ammo options available that will help keep you and your loved ones safe. The round may be a bit niche, but that doesn’t mean it isn’t effective, and the ammo we’ve discussed here definitely proves that.
With the best .357 Sig defense ammo, you should feel confident with wielding a SIG .357 in defense of hearth and home, and you’ll have the bonus of probably being the only one of your buddies to carry one.
For more info, check out our complete list of .357 SIG ammo, or check out our in-depth comparison of .357 SIG and 9mm to see how this slightly niche round stands up to the self-defense king. We also have more info on this great round and how to choose the perfect ammo below.
Cartridge Recommendations
- Best Caliber for Deer Hunting
- Best Big Game Caliber
- The 10 Best Coyote Cartridges
- Best Cartridge for Elk Hunting
- Best Cartridge for Self-Defense
- Best Cartridge for Concealed Carry
- Best Handgun Cartridge
- Best Moose Cartridges
- Best 40 S&W Ammo For Self Defense & Target Practice
- Best 223 Ammo
- Best .44 Magnum Ammo
- Best Shotgun Shell Types for Home Defense & Hunting
- Best 270 Ammo for Hunting
- Best 17 HMR Ammo for Varmint Hunting and Plinking
- Best 22 Rimfire Ammo
- 4 Best AK-47 Ammo Picks [7.62x39]
- Best 38 Special Ammo for Self Defense
- Best Handgun Ammo for Self-Defense in Common Calibers
- Best 308 Ammo For Hunting & Target Shooting
- Best 300 Win Mag Ammo
- Best 243 Ammo for Target Shooting
- 10 Best 6.5 mm Cartridges For Long-Range Shooting and Hunting
- Best 45 ACP Hollow Points for Self-Defense
- Best 12 Gauge Ammo for Home Defense
- Best 32 ACP Ammo for Your Pocket Pistol or Backup Gun
- Top 13 Best AR Calibers That Aren’t 5.56 NATO
- Best Ammo for Smith and Wesson M&P 9mm Shield
- Best 7.62x39 Ammo for Self Defense
- Best 20 Gauge Ammo for Home Defense, Whitetail, and Upland Game
- Best Ammo for 1911 45 ACP
- Best 12 Gauge Ammo for Deer Hunting
- Best .40 S&W Ammo for Self Defense
- Best 7.62x39 Hunting Ammo
- Best 5.56 Ammo for Home Defense
- Best 380 Self-Defense Ammo
- Best 45 ACP Ammo for Every Situation
- Best Ammo for Glock 43x
- Top 5 Best 22 WMR Ammo on the Market
- Best Ammo for Glock 19
- Best Sniper Ammo
- Best 38 Special Ammo For Target Practice Precision Shooting
- Top 5 Best 45 ACP Ammo for Target Practice
- Best 6.5 Creedmoor Hunting Ammo
- Top 10 Best Sniper Rifle Cartridges
- Best 6.5 Grendel Ammo
- Best 5.45x39 Ammo for Your Gun
- Best 10mm Ammo for Bear Defense
- Best 350 Legend Ammo
- Top 5 Best 30-06 Ammo for Deer Hunting
- Best 30-06 Ammo for Accuracy
- Best 300 Win Mag Ammo for Deer
- Best M193 Ammo for Stockpiling
- Best 300 Blackout Ammo for a 7.5" Barrel
- Best Shotgun Shells for Target Practice
- Best 45 ACP for Bear Defense
- Best 223 for Deer Hunting
- Best Exotic 9mm Ammo
- Best Duck Hunting Shells
- Best .357 SIG Defensive Ammo
- Best Beretta APX 9mm Ammo
- Best 22 Pistol Ammo
- Best 9mm Ammo
- Best 308 Ammo for Deer Hunting
- Best Ammo for the Taurus GX4
- Best Ammo For Taurus PT111 G2
- Best Shells For Trap Shooting
- Best 38 Special Ammo for Snubbies
- Best 410 Ammo For A Taurus Judge
- Best Ammo for Ruger Security 9
- Best Ammo for Taurus G3c
- Best 7mm Rem Mag Ammo
- Best Lead-Free Hunting Ammunition
- Best 300 Blackout Ammo for Hog Hunting
- Best 9mm Home Defense Ammo
- Best 10mm Ammo for Every Shooting Situation
- Best .22 LR Ammo for Self-Defense
- Best Long-Range Hunting Bullets
- Best 357 Magnum Ammo For Every Shooting Situation
- Best 45 ACP Ammo For Self-Defense
- Best 6.5 Creedmoor Ammo For Accuracy
- Best 45-70 Ammo For Hunting & Target Shooting
- Best Turkey Loads
- Deadliest Shotgun Ammo For Home Defense
- Best 300 Win Mag Ammo For Elk Hunting
- Best 9mm Subsonic Ammo
- Best 7mm PRC Ammo